Validation · Certification · Defensibility
A glossary of the core concepts that define the EYQA framework. These terms are not interchangeable.
"Recognition follows evidence. It does not precede it."
Narrative Stress-Test
The free, self-administered diagnostic that precedes formal Validation. A 5-minute assessment across six dimensions (Evidence, Logic, Perspective, Risk, Context, Actionability) that surfaces where a narrative is exposed before institutional review. The Stress-Test does not certify — it qualifies and directs toward appropriate next steps.
Validation
Stage I — Establish evidentiary baseline. Validation assesses whether a narrative meets the minimum threshold for certification. It identifies evidence gaps and determines progression eligibility. Validation does not certify — it qualifies narratives for certification.
Certification
Stage II — Formal designation (Bronze/Silver/Gold). Certification confirms that a narrative meets defined defensibility thresholds. Determined exclusively by evidence volume, quality, and replicability. Cannot be purchased or negotiated.
Defensibility
The attribute that validation and certification measure. A narrative is defensible when its claims survive structured scrutiny — from investors, boards, procurement teams, or regulators — without fracturing. Persuasive ≠ defensible.
Stress-Test → Validation → Certification → Defensibility
Each stage builds on the previous. You cannot certify without validating first.
The simplest distinction:
Stress-Test = "Where are we exposed?"
Validation = "Does the evidence exist?"
Certification = "How strong is the evidence?"
Defensibility = "Will it survive scrutiny?"
